8/14/24 – Project management platforms, PMIS, agile culture.
Reading time: 2 minutes
In today’s dynamic business landscape, practitioners face a critical decision: invest in subscription-based platforms or leverage existing resources to build custom solutions. Let’s explore this decision through the lens of practical implementation and strategic value, especially considering the role of business planning creativity and analytics.
Most seasoned pros will tell you stories of times when either budget was available for buy-in to a 3rd party exterior platform or when lack of budget and company culture drove the need for a custom project platform. The largest determining factor in both cases was the need for alignment between executives, supporting analysts, and strategy executioners. All things considered, timing and direct cost are the main considerations of both. #agility #Cost&LaborAnalysis
Subscription platforms prevail with sticky UX, no code processes, and speed. A custom solution typically prevails when cultural UX, custom data points, and data security concerns require a ‘keep it in our firewall’ arrangement. What are some other considerations of both for business planning creativity and analytics?
The Custom Project Management Platform Approach
Advantages of Building In-House
- Perfect alignment with organizational processes
- Complete control over workflow customization
- No recurring subscription costs
- Seamless integration with existing systems
- Enhanced security control
Resource Considerations
Building a custom solution requires:
- Development time investment
- Internal technical expertise
- Ongoing maintenance capability
- Clear understanding of organizational needs for the project management platform
#Customprojectsystems #inhousesolutions #compliance #culture
The Subscription Platform Route
Benefits of Ready-Made Solutions
- Established user communities
- Immediate implementation
- Regular updates and improvements
- Usability and sticky UX
- Professional support
- Proven reliability of the project management platform
#Cost #Budget #Adoption #Speed #UX
Decision Framework
Choose Custom When:
- Data security requirements are stringent
- Your organization has unique workflows that off-the-shelf solutions can’t address
- Internal technical resources are available
- Long-term cost savings are prioritized
Choose Subscription When:
- Predictable monthly costs are preferred
- Quick implementation is needed
- Standard project management features suffice
- Technical resources are limited
Cost Analysis
Custom Development
- Higher initial time investment
- Internal resource allocation
- Lower long-term costs
- Maintenance responsibilities
Subscription Platforms
- Predictable monthly expenses
- Immediate deployment of the project management platform
- Vendor-managed updates
- Professional support included
Strategic Considerations
Scalability
- Custom solutions can grow with specific organizational needs
- Subscription platforms offer standardized scaling options
Integration
- Custom builds enable precise integration with existing tools
- Platform solutions typically offer standard API connections
Making the Final Decision
Consider these key factors:
- Available technical expertise
- Budget structure (capital vs. operational expenses)
- Timeline requirements
- Security needs
- Integration requirements for the project management platform
The choice ultimately depends on your organization’s specific context, resources, and long-term strategic goals. While subscription platforms offer immediate value and proven solutions, custom builds can provide targeted functionality at potentially lower long-term costs when internal resources are available. Business planning creativity and analytics play a crucial role in this decision-making process.
What has your experience been when faced with weighing both options?
https://www.bertwillard.com
#HumanContentAIAssisted
Learn more on this topic:
https://www.itmagination.com/blog/custom-software-vs-saas
https://www.teamwork.com/blog/project-management-information-system
Leave a Reply